The othismos debate

Author: elrw

August undefined, 2024

Webb21 e.g. after a detailed examination of the hoplite's pre-battle tension and fear of massed attack (The Western Way of War, pp. 96-151), he still insists that a massed collision of … WebbThe strongest proponent of the “orthodoxy” is undoubtedly Victor Davis Hanson. A few years ago, there was an attempt to bring the discussion on the hoplite phalanx forward, which resulted in the publication last year of Men of Bronze: Hoplite Warfare in Ancient Greece (edited by Donald Kagan and Gregory Viggiano).

A Proposed Alternative to the Hoplite Debate - SlideShare

Webb4 jan. 2024 · A debate is a formal and organized argument where the participants discuss a subject from two opposing sides. Each topic has two sides. Those who agree with the idea are on the "Pro" side. However, those who disagree are on the "Con" side. Each side presents the argument clearly to engage the audience. Webb@EvanSchultheis @reeshistory @VisualisingWar The reenactment community seems to have an extremely reductive sense of what "orthodox" & "heretic" mean here. I keep seeing these claims that don't make it anywhere past the othismos debate, which is only a tiny fraction of the paradigm shift, and far from the most important. 13 Nov 2024 ray\\u0027s paving solutions

@Othismos Twitter

Webb27 jan. 2024 · When Push Comes to Shove: What Was the "Othismos" of Hoplite Combat? Author(s): Christopher A. Matthew Source: Historia: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte, Bd. 58,… WebbAn incredible amount of ink has been spilled discussing that most thorny of ancient Greek military problems: the hoplite phalanx. In hefty discussions some thirty years ago, two camps emerged. On the one side, we had the “orthodoxy”, which claimed that hoplite equipment and phalanx tactics developed in tandem, no later WebbTo determine if othismos was used to literally mean pushing against an enemy to break their lines, one must look at the practicality of pushing in combat. The main aspect of … ray\u0027s pege monroe

Debate Writing - An Ultimate Guide, Topics and Examples

Views/arguments on the debate over hoplite battle mechanics?

Webbbook has prompted considerable debate among specialist ancient historians, and although much of this has been critical of his ideas (largely due to the alleged anachronism of … Webb13 mars 2024 · Othismos requires that both sides resist, and I would not resist enough to get impaled. Rich would be nice. To take Polybios' extreme case scenario of a pike phalanx in close order with 16 ranks. Visualise the five first men of a pile projecting their pikes all the way to the enemy shield. simply retirement advisor log inhttp://othismos.gallery/ ray\\u0027s pege monroe

"WebbRivista interdisciplinare della Società Italiana di Storia Militare, monografie curate dal Prof. Virgilio Ilari, Periodico telematico open-access annuale (www.nam-sism.org), Gruppo Editoriale Tab Srl " - The othismos debate

The othismos debate

Webb9 sep. 2024 · Othismos, literally meaning pushing, is the supposed concept of ancient greek warfare used by the Phalanx. About 100 years ago an oxford professor decided that the literal translation of Othismos „pushing“ should actually be seen as a mass-pushing similar to American football. The Othismos [4] Hoplite warrior preparing for battle One of the most highly debated aspects of Hoplite warfare is the othismos that occurred when two Hoplite armies clashed on a battlefield. Although the term “Othismos” has multiple meanings, they all focus around the word “push”.

Did you know?

WebbDe senaste tweetarna från @Othismos Webb20 jan. 2024 · Othismos is a noun that derives from a verb meaning “to push”. The clearest way to make a noun from a verb is to describe it as “a state when that verb occurs”. Thus …

http://www.colonvillechurch.org/pastorsblog/taking-a-stand-the-othismos-declaration Webb28 maj 2016 · Dr. Jeanne Reames Director, Ancient Mediterranean Studies Graduate Studies Chair University of Nebraska, Omaha 287 ASH; 6001 Dodge Street Omaha NE 68182

Webb17 jan. 2024 · 1. Understand the Debate. The first step to write a debate is by understanding its nature. Here, both teams will be given a topic, and they will choose an affirmative or negative stance. 2. Research the Topic Thoroughly. Brainstorm and research the topic thoroughly to understand all the aspects of the debate. Webb11 juli 2014 · The orthodoxy defines the early Greek polis as the result of a sudden change or “revolution” in military equipment and tactics which drove social and political …

WebbThe Harper’s Bazaar Archive includes the backfiles of the US and UK editions of Harper’s Bazaar. In combination, these publications comprise almost 500,000 pages of content from 1867 to the present, representing a vast and indispensable resource for the study of fashion and related fields. Give us your feedback.

WebbCall it inflation, or supply chain issues, or the way it is, but buying a car these days is like looking for a new home. Check out this report at Fortune: The average monthly payment for a new car has soared to a record $777, nearly doubling from late 2024, according to Kelley Blue Book owner Cox Automotive. ray\\u0027s paving \\u0026 drainage incWebb3 feb. 2024 · ROB changes the laws of the universe such that if any civilization could produce iron in any quantity, they could build a "camera". All iron age civilizations would have this capability, they just need to produce a bit of iron. Assume that the "cameras" have the following properties: 1) They... ray\\u0027s pege menuWebb1 jan. 1997 · The Othismos, Myths and Heresies: The Nature of Hoplite Battle A. Goldsworthy Published 1 January 1997 History War in History W hat actually happened … ray\\u0027s performance auto in north conway nhWebbScholars frequently debate the meanings of classical words that do not necessarily have direct modern language parallels. Words like the Greek and the Latin othismos virtus are poorly understood, and modern scholars strive to provide these words with specific definitions. The Romans saw their virtus, a term often simply retirement websiteWebbA mikveh is a bath used for the purpose of ritual immersion to achieve ritual purity in Judaism. The traditional rules regarding the construction of a mikveh are based on those specified in regulations laid down in the Torah and in classical rabbinical literature.The text describes how a mikveh must be connected to a natural spring or well of naturally … ray\u0027s pawn shop rainelle wvWebb29 okt. 2013 · Another plus is that it can be really useful to start with a different opinion, when you’re thinking of points your opponents might make during a debate, and how to counter them. 3. Look for the grey areas. All of the debates I have taken part in so far have involved very large grey areas, rather than being simply black and white. simply retro chijmesWebbTaking a Stand: The Othismos Declaration Today is July 4th, the anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence. On this very day in 1776, the Continental Congress declared that the thirteen American colonies were no longer... ray\u0027s paving solutions